I finally got my hands on a Sugar Doctor…

From the day I first read on the net that Dr. Pepper would be celebrating its 125th anniversary with a limited edition REAL sugar version of its spicy cola, I was having Pepsi Throwback throwbacks I mean, flashbacks. I was SO excited to once again experience a soda the way it tasted in my youth.
After weeks of stopping at every grocery store, Target, Walmart and 7-11 I passed, I finally found Sugar Doctor—and immediately bought three 12-packs. Once I got them home, I had to try my patience by leaving the Sugar Doctor in the fridge for HOURS before tasting it. See, I will NOT try an all new soda experience with ice, because when warm soda hits cold ice, the ice IMMEDIATELY begins to melt INTO the soda and messes with the natural taste of the soda, essentially rendering the soda flat by watering it down.
So it was around 9 at night that I finally snapped open my first can. The fizzy sweetness touched my lips and…well…I was so NOT blown away. It didn’t taste all that different than the crappy corn syrup version of Dr. Pepper. The only real difference I noted was that it was a bit ‘cleaner’ or ‘purer’ tasting, with no pasty aftertaste coating my mouth. What went wrong? Were my taste buds off? Where was the sugary wonder I’d experienced with Pepsi Throwback? And how cruel are the hands of fate to keep me awake all night with only my disappointment as company while I watched Roseanne reruns on TV Land waiting for the late night caffeine injection to wear off?
It appears that instead of using PURE cane sugar like Pepsi Throwback, this real sugar Dr. Pepper has used a cheaper alternative called liquid ‘beet’ sugar, whatever the hell that means—sounds like nothing more than an alternative corn syrup to me. At least this appears to be the situation based on what I could discern from the crazy people on the net who have nothing better to do with their time than obsess over this ridiculous soda stuff. That’s why I had to have a corn syrup Dr. Pepper/Sugar Doctor taste test with my friends at work the next day!
Yeah, we used the blindfolds and all. There were four of us, me and three females, and the results were absolutely convoluted and inconclusive. One of the females pointed out that it could have something to do with which of them was at which point in their ‘cycles’ and how that affected their desire for sweets. Another problem was the unfair playing field—see, I had the limited edition Sugar Doctor in a can, and the guy who fills the vending machine at my job decided THAT week to stop featuring corn syrup Dr. Pepper cans in its vending machine. I had to make a special run to a deli, where I could only find corn syrup Dr. Pepper in a plastic bottle. And the simply fact is, soda does not taste as good in a plastic bottle as it does in a can. So it would seem that corn syrup Dr. Pepper was at a disadvantage.
And yet, Sugar Doctor didn’t win the taste test. Myself and one of the females both ended up selecting the Sugar Doctor as the cleaner tasting drink with no aftertaste. Yet the other two females BOTH liked corn syrup Dr. Pepper better, claiming it was ‘sweeter’. However, they did detect the filmy aftertaste. Meanwhile, some guy walked by who is a passionate Dr. Pepper lover but has stopped drinking soda, so he wanted to just SMELL the sodas to see if he could detect which was the real sugar variety. Another co-worker later pointed out he had a 50/50 chance of getting it right, but at the time he took the sniff test, we four tasters were in awe that he matter-of-factly pointed to the Sugar Doctor as the one with the real sugar. I still don’t know how, on the soda wagon or not, he didn’t at least TRY a sip of the stuff.
So anyway, we figured we needed a taste tiebreaker, so we found another candidate—again a female co-worker! PLUS, this chick doesn’t even LIKE Dr. Pepper. Anyway, it turns out she actually liked the Sugar Doctor better but only because she felt it wasn’t as sweet as the regular Dr. Pepper with corn syrup.
So I guess we could say three out of five people preferred the Sugar Doctor, even though one of those who ‘preferred’ it simply disliked it less than Dr. Pepper with corn syrup. A general consensus seemed to be that corn syrup made the soda sweeter, which was fine for those who like it sweeter and are willing to suffer the yucky aftertaste. In the meantime, I’m having more friends over this weekend to share in Sugar Doctor with me. Perhaps I’ll be able to score a can of the corn syrup version so everything can be on a more even playing field—especially since there will actually be more men than women doing the tasting.


